Understanding Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD): A Comprehensive Guide

Blogs

Secure Data Movement in Azure Data Factory: Best Practices
September 20, 2024
Microsoft SQL Server Execution Plan Analysis
September 22, 2024

Understanding Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD): A Comprehensive Guide

In the world of data warehousing, handling changes to dimensions over time is a critical challenge. As organizations grow and evolve, so does their data. Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD) is a concept used in data warehouses to track and manage historical changes to dimension data. In this blog, we will explore what SCD is, the various types of SCD, and how they are implemented.

What are Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD)?

Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD) refer to the method used to manage and track changes in the dimension tables of a data warehouse. Dimension tables contain descriptive attributes (dimensions) that define facts in a fact table. Unlike fact tables, which are updated frequently, dimensions change less often. However, when changes occur, it is important to decide how to manage these changes without losing historical context.

For example, consider a retail store’s customer dimension. A customer may move to a new address or change their name, and we need to capture this change in a way that preserves the customer’s history.

Types of Slowly Changing Dimensions

There are three main types of SCD, each handling changes differently:

SCD Type 0: Retaining Original Values

SCD Type 0 is used when the original value of a dimension attribute is critical and should not be changed. This type is often used for attributes that are not expected to change frequently or where historical accuracy is essential.

Example:
If a product is assigned a unique identifier (SKU) that should never change, SCD Type 0 would ensure that the SKU remains constant in the dimension table, even if other attributes of the product change.

Advantages:

  • Preserves the original value without changes.
  • Simple to implement for certain attributes.

Disadvantages:

  • Limited flexibility; not suitable for attributes that may change over time.

SQL Implementation Example:

SELECT * FROM product_dimension

WHERE product_id = 1;

 

SCD Type 1: Overwriting the Existing Data

In Type 1 SCD, when there is a change in dimension data, the old data is simply overwritten with the new data. There is no history of the previous values. This approach is suitable when tracking historical changes is not important.

Example:
If a customer changes their address, the old address is replaced with the new one in the table. The old address is no longer available.

Advantages:

  • Simple and easy to implement.
  • No need for additional storage or complex queries.

Disadvantages:

  • Loss of historical data.

SQL Implementation Example:

UPDATE customer_dimension

SET address = ‘New Address’

WHERE customer_id = 1;

 

SCD Type 2: Creating a New Record

SCD Type 2 maintains full historical data by creating a new record each time a change occurs. It adds a new row with the updated information while preserving the original row. To differentiate between the historical and current data, additional columns like StartDate, EndDate, or a flag (IsCurrent) are often added.

Example:
If a customer changes their address, a new row is inserted with the updated address, while the old row remains with an EndDate marking when the change occurred.

Advantages:

  • Preserves historical data.
  • Allows tracking changes over time.

Disadvantages:

  • More storage space is required.
  • Queries can become more complex.

SQL Implementation Example:

UPDATE customer_dimension

SET EndDate = GETDATE(), IsCurrent = 0

WHERE customer_id = 1 AND IsCurrent = 1;

 

INSERT INTO customer_dimension (customer_id, name, address, StartDate, IsCurrent)

VALUES (1, ‘John Doe’, ‘New Address’, GETDATE(), 1);

 

SCD Type 3: Adding a New Column

SCD Type 3 handles changes by adding new columns to store both the old and the new values of the changed attribute. This approach is useful when only the previous version of data is needed, but not the entire history.

Example:
If a customer changes their address, a new column PreviousAddress is created to store the old value, while the Address column stores the new value.

Advantages:

  • Retains both old and new values.
  • Simple to query, as it stores only two versions.

Disadvantages:

  • Only tracks limited history.
  • Not scalable for multiple changes.

SQL Implementation Example:

UPDATE customer_dimension

SET PreviousAddress = Address, Address = ‘New Address’

WHERE customer_id = 1;

 

Other Types of SCD

In addition to the main types, there are some advanced SCD types:

  • SCD Type 4: Separate Historical Table
    In this approach, historical data is maintained in a separate table, allowing the current table to hold only the latest information.
  • SCD Type 6: Hybrid (Type 1 + Type 2 + Type 3)
    A combination of Types 1, 2, and 3, which adds both a history tracking column and an indicator column to maintain a full change history.

Choosing the Right SCD Type

Selecting the appropriate SCD type depends on your business requirements. Here are a few factors to consider:

  1. Is historical data important?
    If you need to retain historical data, choose Type 2 or Type 3. If history is irrelevant, Type 1 is sufficient.
  2. How frequently do changes occur?
    If changes are rare, Type 2 may be preferable. However, if changes are frequent and you only need to retain recent history, Type 3 might be a better choice.
  3. What is the impact on performance?
    Type 1 has the least overhead since it overwrites data. Type 2 requires more storage and could impact performance for large datasets due to the additional rows.

Best Practices for Implementing SCD

  • Plan for Growth:
    As the dimension grows, especially in Type 2, ensure your infrastructure can handle the additional storage and processing.
  • Use Surrogate Keys:
    Instead of using natural keys (e.g., customer IDs), it is better to use surrogate keys, which can simplify managing changes.
  • Performance Optimization:
    Create indexes on key columns like StartDate and EndDate in Type 2 to optimize querying historical data.
  • Archiving:
    For Type 2 SCD, consider an archiving strategy to manage older records that are no longer frequently queried.

Conclusion

Slowly Changing Dimensions (SCD) play a crucial role in data warehousing by helping to track changes over time in dimension tables. The choice of SCD type depends on your organization’s needs for retaining historical data and managing changes. Whether you opt for the simplicity of Type 1, the comprehensive history tracking of Type 2, or the limited history of Type 3, understanding the pros and cons of each type will help you build a robust and efficient data warehouse.

That’s all from this blog until next time.. keep learning..


Lochan R

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *